Don't you just love it when a new guy joins the Forum and digs up a bunch of old Threads?
Like many of you, I have a pile of "favorite" rifles. I have stocked or re-stocked most of my hunting rifles, with probably 100+ hours of work into each one. This includes shaping and finishing, glass and pillar bedding the action and barrel channel, and hand checkering a multi-panel pattern that I have on four of my rifles. With all that time and TLC, each one becomes a favorite.
When I first started hunting it was easy to name my favorite rifle. I only had one. It was a .30-06 barreled action and semi-finished stock that I bought from Herter's when I was in college. It was also the first stock that I checkered. Living in NW Colorado and then in NW Montana, I shot a pile of mule deer, pronghorns, and elk with that rifle.
Just before I moved to SW Montana, I had a Kalispel gunsmith re-chamber that .30-06 to .30 Gibbs. For the next 25 years, that was my favorite elk rifle, taking an elk almost every year with it and also a couple of moose, a mtn goat, and an Alaskan caribou.
As I got more into hunting and shooting, I decided I needed more than one rifle. So I got my next favorite rifle. I ordered a Mauser Mark X barreled action in .20-06 and semi-finished fancy walnut stock from Fajen. Before I put them together, I had that Kalispel gunsmith re-chamber it to .257 Ackley. For the past 30 or so years, this has been my favorite rifle for deer and pronghorn antelope size animals. I've also been lucky enough to shoot 3 bighorn rams and a Dall ram, a mountain caribou, and one of my largest 6-pt bull elk with it.
About the time I built my .257 Ackley, I decided I needed gopher/groundhog rifle, so I ordered another Mauser Mark X action and had the Kalispel gunsmith make me a tapered octagon barrel chambered in .22-250 for it. Another semi-finished fancy walnut stock from Fajen, and I got my favorite varmint rifle. It has also worked for several deer and pronghorns.
About five years ago I decided to upgrade my "plane Jane" black Remington 700 ADL in 7mm Rem Mag to a more all weather Model 700 BDL with a Stainless Steel barrel and action and a composite stock that would fit me. A little work on the trigger, glass bedding the action and barrel channel, a 1/2" spacer and a Limbsaver recoil pad and I now had my favorite foul weather rifle, good for anything from pronghorn antelope in the rain to elk in a snowstorm.
In 2005 I booked a Cape Buffalo hunt in Zimbabwe. I needed a DG rifle. I had a .375 H&H in a Model 700 Rem Classic, but it wasn't exactly what I wanted. After some research, I ordered a new Remington 700 LSS with a 26" Stainless Steel barrel chambered in .375 Rem Ultra Mag. The first trip to the range with my new .375 RUM convinced me that I had some recoil taming to do. A new grey/rose laminated semi finished stock from Richards, a trigger job, pillar and glass bedding the action and barrel channel, a KDF muzzle brake, a mechanical recoil reducer, a Limbsaver pad, and topped with a 2 x 7 Leupold, and I have my favorite African rifle.
This .375 RUM has been with me to Africa twice. The first time I shot 300 gr TSX bullets through it to take a buffalo and 4 other PG animals from bushbuck to Zebra. This was the only rifle that I took for my last trip to the Eastern Cape region of South Africa in 2007. On this trip I shot 270 gr TSX bullets and shot 13 PG animals from Steenbok to Cape Eland. Shots were from 30 yds for the Eland to 348 yds for a Gemsbok, including two prone shots at 220 and 250 yds for Black Springbok and Vaal Rhebok. Recoil was not a factor on any of the shots, and most shots were DRT one shot kills.
I traded my .375 H&H for a Remington model 541T in .22 LR. It's topped with a 3 x 9 Simmons scope and a 1" recoil pad makes the length of pull close to that of my hunting rifle. This rifle easily shoots 3" groups at 100 yds which makes it a great rifle for inexpensive practice. It is my favorite .22 rifle.
A couple of years ago I began having some problems with my .30 Gibbs so I decided to build a .300 Weatherby. I bought a Weatherby Vanguard in .300 Wby and ordered a fancy Claro walnut semi finished stock from Richards for it. I had a KDF muzzle brake installed on the barrel, pillar and glass bedded the action and barrel channel, installed a mercury recoil reducer in the stock, polished and adjusted the trigger, installed a Limbsaver pad, and topped it with a 4 x 12 Leupold scope. It will shoot several different bullets into 3-shot 1" groups at 100 yds at from 3100-3200 fps. I haven't shot anything but paper with it yet, but I'm sure it will become my favorite all around rifle.