Holsters are personal. They have to fit the handgun, provide concealment in most cases today, and fit your body for an all day carry. Most of us have more than a few holsters that just don't or did not work for us. Different situations may also necessitate use of different holsters.
I like leather for comfort. Kydex holsters are less expensive and are functional but cold against the skin and most have uncomfortable sharp or pointy edges. They are however very handy to slip on and off. I use them for small frame automatics.
For everyday carry (EDC) I now use Palmetto Leather holsters. They are very comfortable even with a 1911 Commander.
Andrews Leather, of which I have a few, makes fine holsters. Sam Andrews made all the leather for the movie The Magnificent Seven staring Denzel Washington.
I also have an old Bianchi 110 that just plane works good.
I have a Galco OWB that carrys great for a "walk in the woods".
Milt Sparks' Summer Service Special, or something like that, also carrys good.
Everyone is different in their build, walk, draw, lifestyle, and so on.
Best of luck finding what works best for you!