Tex84, since you're a fellow Texan I feel I can be frank with you and you can relate to what I'm saying. I've hunted both SA and Namibia. Most of SA is hunting on smaller, high fenced game ranches that stock game on a put and take basis, regardless of what you may read or be told. Hunting is very similar to these same type high fenced operations in the Texas Hill Country. Namibia on the other hand, properties may or may not be high fenced, but hunting is done on much larger properties, often times 20,000 acres or more. This type of arrangement is much more to my personal taste. I also refuse to hunt with outfitters who charge trophy fees on a sliding scale basis. Too many great places in Namibia for instance that do not do this.
Since both types of hunting, SA game ranches and the more wide open spaces of Namibia are entirely legal, you can make up your mind as to what your personal thoughts are. There are big kudu to be had both ways, but even if the odds are bigger in SA (not saying they are), small high fences aren't my style. I'll even say I was kind of fooled once, but won't happen again. Finding out exactly what you're getting into can be tougher than you would think with regards to getting some SA safari operators to be 100% factual. Sometimes you don't know what you don't know........ya know?