Montana Whitetail

jeff

AH legend
Joined
Sep 21, 2010
Messages
2,603
Reaction score
2,257
Location
Salmon Idaho
Media
48
Hunting reports
Africa
23
USA/Canada
1
Member of
sci P&Y
Hunted
Namibia, South Africa in Kwazu Natal, Limpopo, Eastern Cape , Northwest Province, USA Ariz, Nev, Mont, Ida, Ore, Cal, Mich,Wash, AlasKa
Jeff buck 1 my camera.jpg
Jeffs deer 2 my camera.jpg
Montana deer 1.jpg
Montana deer 2.jpg
Deer heart.jpg


The 17th of Nov. was a good day, while he isn't like the Midwest giants he's a good buck for out here and me. Taken in the general season 17 yards from a tree stand after a few all day sits at 3pm. Four big jumps and I watched him pile up. A P&Y whitetail has been kind of a bucket list thing for me after taking 5 deer that wouldn't quite make it after deductions. The buck green scores 141 and nets 134 because of the missing G4. So I finally got my P&Y buck!
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Awesome!!! You couldn’t have made a better shot based on the pic of that heart!!!
 
Nice buck, congrats!
 
Nice buck! What part of Montana were you hunting?
 
Nice buck Jeff! You couldn’t have center punched that heart any better with GPS, radar and an anatomical chart.
 
Congrats, nice buck @jeff!
 
I should have mentioned that I was shooting a Bowtech assassin at 63# with a 420 grain arrow.
 
How is the meat flavor? I’m curious if others experience a different flavor with older bucks like that. I’ve only ever had one deer that I thought the meat flavor was off.
 
Great buck from my old stomping grounds! Congratulations!
 
How is the meat flavor? I’m curious if others experience a different flavor with older bucks like that. I’ve only ever had one deer that I thought the meat flavor was off.
The meat is excellent. I was worried that he might be strong but he had almost no odor and the meat is tender. He's.also the fattest deer I've ever taken with up to a inch and a half all over his back and hams.
 
I’m sure a perfect shot like that helped to keep the meat free of any adrenaline!

I personally think thanksgiving dinner should be an entire rare/medium rare backstrap!
 
Very good shooting. Nice buck anywhere. Congrats
Bruce
 
Congratulations. Montana whitetail is on my bucket list
 
Congratulations! Nice buck, nice shot, and nice to fill the freezer! Awesome
 

Forum statistics

Threads
58,980
Messages
1,275,121
Members
106,475
Latest member
TDVCIII
 

 

 

Latest posts

Latest profile posts

Finally! Been a month now, retired to Western Cape, SA! Living my best life!
Justin Peterson wrote on Jager Waffen74's profile.
Pics of the 375 nosier partitions appreciated. 801-455-9909
Preparing for the adventure of a lifetime. Looking forward to my 2026 Africa hunt with Van Wijk Safaris in South Africa.
Monster Free range Common Reedbuck!!
34d2250a-fe9a-4de4-af4b-2bb1fde9730a.jpeg
ef50535d-e9e2-4be7-9395-aa267be92102.jpeg
 
Top