Eeleel,
Had the same questions as you did prior to my first trip to Africa last year. I did a lot of reading here on AH and saw arguments for both having the trophies done here in the States or in Africa. It really came down to the following: I wanted quality work done that I would be proud to display in my living room for all to see, not shoved into the garage, shed or hunting camp.
That meant QUALITY. Can you be assured of quality mounts from Africa? Not that I have read. Many many horror stories, even from reputable Taxidermists in South Africa and there are many on here that have received good work and that they are happy with the work. Take a look through the Taxidermy section and zoom in and look at the work up close. If you I don't like or have an issue with your mount, are you going to send it back to Africa?
COST is usually a consideration for many, some not as much. If you are of the former, there are significant costs that need budgeted, I'll get to that later. Comparing the costs of mounting them in Africa vs the States. In most cases it's very close, in other cases (Giraffe comes to mind) there is a big difference. You will need to do the analysis based upon the animals you want to mount. My bag of standard plains game didn't have any big cost drivers to sway me to using a Taxidermist from Africa. Here is a link to my first hunt. I'm doing 5 shoulder mounts, 2 rugs and the rest euro, I'm also keeping a running tally of costs and timelines to help first timers understand the costs and time it takes to get their trophies home.
https://www.africahunting.com/threads/south-africa-kmg-safaris-rocks.39278/
Just to have my trophies dipped/packed, cleared through customs and shipped to the tannery was $3400. If you have your trophies mounted in Africa, I would expect the shipping charges to be higher due to the additional volume. I'm expecting my Taxidermy bill to run ~$7k.
Based on the outstanding quality of work with price not being a driving factor I chose Dennis Harris
@The Artistry of Wildlife. Dennis will gladly give you a quote, drop him a PM or shoot him an e-mail.
Don't forget to hire a clearing agent, I used Michael @ Coppersmiths in the Chicago office, highly recommended.
If you have any additional questions, let us know.
Edge