My '99 Jimmy finally bought the farm this past fall when it bagged a big whitetail doe in Eastern Montana. Since 2010 I have hit four deer with that rig on the same one hour stretch of highway, two of them in the same spot ... ten years apart. Anyway, I have been able to drive away every time. But with 340K miles, a ruined tire, muffler just gave out, and transmission slipping into first gear, it was time to say goodbye. It's been a great hunting outfit for me and my dogs. These days it had a carrier hitch on the back as well as Tule carrier on top. But I remember a few years back when it had two mule deer bucks on top (one inside the carrier). Hated to see it go but no sense it putting any more money in it.
So I bought a 2003 Envoy as replacement. A lot of miles but in excellent condition. I think it will work out fine. I loved the tailgate on the Jimmy for the dogs. On the road I can pop up the window to feed or water them as needed. The Envoy is hatchback but it does have rear window that pops up separately which is good enough. Actually it's probably better. To get the dogs out of the Jimmy required popping up the window first to drop the tailgate. My Lab gets too wound up when we are hunting and will bale out over the tailgate when window is opened. I believe it's how she tore her ACL in 2023.
This Envoy has same size engine as the Jimmy but it is in-line six (Jimmy was V6). Like the 4-Runner, these Envoys are supposed to be a bit hard on mpg (not as bad as 4-Runner though). However, returning with it to Ontario last month I was actually impressed with the mpg, especially considering I was driving against a helluva east wind across the prairies. Did much better than the Jimmy which is a smaller vehicle. This Envoy does have a lot more power and should handle my 19' camper trailer if needed (it stays in Montana). VERY comfortable to drive.
My daughter has a three year-old 4-Runner and she was convinced that's what I needed. Curiously, they're not nearly as popular in Montana (GM reigns supreme it seems) and I was shopping for used vehicle there. Her outfit I find very uncomfortable. Seats are horrible and the ride is stiffer. This Envoy is slightly higher than the Jimmy (which I found ideal for ease of access and clearance) but the 4-Runner is too high for my tastes. I hate having to shoehorn myself into low riding cars or climbing up into high riding pickups. 4-Runner does have a good reputation for reliability but some new monster pickups get better mpg. Buying American is not such a big deal for me, especially after the events of last few days. However, buying a used vehicle in Montana made a LOT of sense (it had been planned before hitting the deer). No road salt (on east side anyway) and no sales tax. I can pick up a twenty year-old vehicle and it's worth fixing up. Ten year-old vehicle from Ontario is a disintegrated rust heap. My Jimmy lasted as long as it did because I didn't drive it in the winter. Exchange rate is horrible so that almost offset the tax savings. But for integrity retained in used vehicles there's just no comparison. I'll never buy used in Ontario.