Charlie, I freely admit that I'm biased. I like things that are simple and robust. The Excaliber Crossbow is just that. Their newest model with the reverse limbs is extremely narrow and should work well in confined spaces like a tree stand. My Excaliber is the older Matrix model. It consistently puts multiple bolts into a 2" circle at fifty yards. The boys and I have used them on a number of Deer and Hogs. Although I don't recommend doing it, supposedly the Excaliber can be dry-fired without damaging the bow. I'm not aware of other manufacturers making that same claim. As far as the noise is concerned there are a number of Excaliber accessories to reduce it. I've taken old bucks from my tree stand at 40 & 50 yards, neither made any move to "jump" the arrow.